You must log in or register to comment.
If the island were 100 times larger, the houses would take 1% of the land area, leaving 99%. The apartment complex would take up .04%, leaving 99.96%, which isn’t much of an improvement. The proportions of our planet are much closer to my scenario than this made up island. That’s a reason why we might not “prefer apartments in our own town.”
There are good reasons you might want density, this just isn’t one of them.
That’s the difference between America and Western Europe. Western Europe is already mostly built up, they don’t have room. America does.
The picture on the left is just an argument against lawns.
Right? And also…who needs space between two homes if there are no lawns? Just moosh all the outer walls together.
Come to think of it…that’s gonna result in a ridiculously long line of houses. Maybe we could moosh roofs and bottom floors and stack 'em up a bit to make the line of houses only a half to a third as long, and then leave a little space between Consecutive House Stacks™️ - y’know, so that there’ll room for more windows.
Lawns aren’t the reason people want to have space from their neighbors.
I’ll go with 99 apartments and one house on the other side so I can be as far from them as possible.
What makes you think it would be just one apartment building instead of filling the island with apartment buildings?
For the same amount of people, you wouldn’t need to.
Who says only X amount of people will move to the island? The island will always fill up over time, at least with suburbs, there will be some green left
But then you have to live in an apartment…
The neighbors kids who live above you will stomp around at 2:00am.
The neighbors below you will complain when you make the slightest noise.
I guess that’s just an argument for better made apartments.
Logic here is broken because we don’t make these decisions anyway. A developer will instead put 30 apartment buildings while chopping down anything that gets in the way, then charge more for rent than you’d be charged for the mortgage on the house. There’s also the fact that this picture assumes every family on the left pic doesn’t give a fuck about free scaping, preserving trees, or planting new ones? Idk, whole thing is jacked.
the simplest solution is to stop having so many babies. population reduction is critical to quality of life.
That’s not a real solution.
You see one apartment building. A property developer sees room for 100 apartment buildings.
Now imagine apartment buildings taking up 100% of the island and that’s what you get under the current system.
